I consistently completely turn off my mobile device when I enter a cinema. Not just on vibrate – all the way off. I share this not from a place of judgment, or to suggest that the spirit of a film legend will return to offer approval. I see it as one of life's minor indulgences: for at least an hour and a half, I exist as totally incommunicado. I leave my phone off during the end credits as well. It seems luxurious to remain seated as fellow attendees gradually exit, illuminated solely by the closing titles.
And, more and more, by the light of the cataloguing app.
Over millions of people engage with Letterboxd, a film-cataloguing application. Like the Criterion Collection, it has become industry shorthand for a specific type of influencer who promotes latest films and revels in rediscovering old classics. Patrons score and write about films, and the most insightful or most articulate critiques become popular, motivating movie buffs to write diligently.
"Unless I articulate my impressions quickly when the film concludes, my write-ups are much less coherent and articulate," remarked a student.
On a recent visit to the cinema, the scroll was just commencing before the patron seated in front of me started composing his assessment. Not far away, a couple remained seated, heads bowed, recording their individual impressions.
The legendary director David Lynch had a piece of advice: record every spark of inspiration the precise instant it occurs to you. If you don't, it could vanish, and, as he put it: "Forgetting a good idea, you feel like you could commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to aspiring film-makers, a similar ethos pertains to the act of reviewing.
One young man, a twenty-year-old university attendee in New York, always writes his assessments while still in the cinema.
"If I don't get my thoughts out promptly once the movie ends, my reviews are significantly less lucid and well-put," he said. "It requires a while. I'm pretty slow, and my girlfriend gets impatient."
He goes to the movies a great deal – 182 times in a single year – and is on a first-name basis with the cinema employees, who sometimes must usher him out so they can commence sweeping the aisles. He considers it perfectly fair to take advantage of the end credits: "Upon buying a theater ticket, the closing sequence are part of the film experience."
The platform's most ardent supporters give credit to the service with reviving interest around a struggling movie business, where output has decreased and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also has the type of user profile advertisers covet – its biggest group of users is between 18 and 24, followed by 25 to 35.)
Buzz creates more hype; much-hyped movies witness a flurry of reviews on Letterboxd shortly following the initial screenings. The highest-rated review of an acclaimed film version – "Emily Brontë succumbed long ago yet this adaptation is still the worst thing that has ever affected her" – has received in excess of 50,000 hearts. A different pop culture movie produced this contrast to a rival's documentary: "the Eras Tour documentary left in the dust."
"It feels like a compulsion," remarked a marketing professional, a thirty-three-year-old resident who is employed in marketing. He also prefers to write reviews in the end sequence. "Thinking about what you just witnessed, immediately after you experienced it, aids the viewing experience. It helps you grasp the central themes of a film. If it evokes a feeling of a warm hug, that's hardly something you remember hours later."
He feels most motivated to write about a film if it was brilliant – or awful. For example: he recently watched a sci-fi vehicle. "I was actually so appalled by how utterly terrible it was, that I was excited to take out my phone and award it a half-star review," he noted. (He is a more critical critic than some film critics, who awarded the film three stars, labeling it "smart and entertaining stuff.")
Another user, a twenty-eight-year-old New Yorker who is in social media, viewed a fantasy animated film at a local theater and remained to compose the assessment ("it got the highest rating"). He has witnessed poorer etiquette: people pulling out their phones to review the movie they are actively viewing. "That behavior annoys me," he said.
One of the movie industry's longest-running tales recounts a exhibition of an early silent short that featured a train entering a station. Film was in its earliest days and – in line with this apocryphal anecdote – the footage of a locomotive heading straight toward the camera shocked the spectators so much that people fled screaming.
Many decades later, audience behavior remains just as problematic. It seems, no one knows how to act in public anymore, especially when the lights dim: viewers snap photos of the image, bring in strong-smelling food, and, as seen during a cultural moment, sometimes participate in fights.
A number of users have resorted to social media to debate the acceptability of "Letterboxding" during the closing scroll. When one social media user